Olive Specter’s Timeline #1: Early Years – Danielle Greaves, Earl E. DeMise

70 years before the start of STSYC, the sim who would later be known as “Olive Specter” came into the sim world as “Olive Muenda”, the first-born child of Peponi and Lerato Muenda.

Five years later, Olive welcomed a younger sister, Willow Muenda, who would later become the mother of Ophelia Nigmos.

Muenda Family: Peponi, Lerato, Olive Specter, Willow Nigmos
Muenda Family (1963), 55 years before STSYC (2018)

The Muenda sisters’ temperaments could not be more different. Olive was the precocious and rebellious one, while Willow was more conventional and obedient. Nonetheless, they got along reasonably well.


One afternoon, when Olive was 15 and Willow was 10, they were at home alone. Olive was busy setting up an ant farm for her school project.

Young Olive Specter & Willow Nigmos with the ant farm

As she had yet to bring the project to school, the teachers and her family were unaware that Olive had chosen a dangerous species of bulldog ants.

Since Willow was hungry, and the stove was broken, Olive decided to be a good older sister, and order a pizza.

Danielle Greaves delivers pizza to the Muenda household

Danielle Greaves was sent to the Muenda house to deliver the pizza. As Willow paid for the order, Danielle caught sight of Olive with her ant farm, and made an off-color remark about Olive being a “school nerd”… a deadly error which did not escape Olive’s attentive ears.

Danielle Greaves offends young Olive Specter (Muenda)

Olive “allowed” one of the ants to escape. It ran up to Danielle and bit her. Willow did not understand how Danielle could suddenly be inflicted with spasms of pain that led to unconsciousness… and sudden death. Apparently, the ant poisoning depleted most of Danielle’s need bars, especially Hunger.

Danielle Greaves dies

Grim Reaper Thanatos Grimm arrives for Danielle Greaves' death

That was also the first time Olive saw the dark-hooded figure who came to claim the pizza girl’s soul. She was deeply fascinated by his air of mystery.

Teen Olive Specter sees Grim Reaper Thanatos Grimm for the first time

Olive tried her best to hide her satisfied moodlet, by calmly telling her sister that “bad things happen to those who make fun of Olive Muenda”. They quickly buried Danielle nearby, and agreed never to speak of this again.

Young Olive Specter & Willow Nigmos (Muenda) eat pizza

As Willow tried her best to drown out that terrifying memory with the fresh pizza, Olive released the bulldog ants into the wild, and returned with a more harmless species for her project.

Olive knew that the Danielle Greaves incident was her defining moment. For the rest of her life, she would abide by the maxims she learned that day:

Do it quickly. Eliminate all evidence even more quickly.

The last anyone ever heard of Danielle Greaves for a long time was the TV appeal for witnesses of her disappearance.

Glarn & Kitty Curious watch TV, while young Jenny Smith plays nearby

Glarn Curious: Maybe the aliens abducted her!

Kitty Curious: Even little Jenny (#) is too old for that sort of fairy tales.

After that nasty accident, everything went back to normal. The rest of Olive’s teenhood went on smoothly.

When she hit adulthood, she got a decently-paying job as a Projectionist… and a rich boyfriend.

Young Olive Specter and Earl E DeMise

EARL E. DEMISE (45 years before STSYC)

Olive met Earl E. DeMise at a nectary. He was a travelling salesman, who had inherited a fortune of simoleons. His Eloquent and Jokester (^) traits made him a charming catch. But he also admitted to Olive that he was a Misanthrope (^), which she could clearly notice from the way he treated other sims.

Young Olive Specter watches Earl E DeMise being rude to a waitress

After they had dated for a while…

“Earl E, I love this place so much! They serve the finest nectar in the whole area. Did you know I always liked nectar?”

Olive Specter & Earl E DeMise dating

“I guess so, Olive, dear.”

“When we were going to get engaged, dear? I’ve seen this beautiful engagement ring which would suit me perfectly.”

“Engaged…? Oh yeah, that’s right…” Earl E. instinctively pulled off a ring from his own finger, and put it on the table. “OK, I’ve bought this ring. I hope it’s expensive enough for you…”

“OH EARL! Of course I want to marry you!”

“I can’t wait…” Earl E muttered tentatively under his breath. The smile on his face was giving him cramps.

Only Olive Specter is enthusiastic about the proposal of Earl E DeMise

The wedding preparations went on so quickly. All Olive could think about was her future life with the charming man of her dreams, the life she dreamt about as a child.

Finally, the moment arrived…

Young Olive Specter (Muenda) first attempt at a wedding

Olive: Where could he possibly be? We’ve been waiting for half an hour.

Willow: It’s OK, Olive, he can be here any moment.

Another 30 minutes later…

Willow Nigmos fails to comfort Olive Specter at her first wedding attempt

Olive: C’mon, why isn’t he here yet? This is the most special day of our lives!

Willow: I have no idea! Maybe he got into an accident?

Olive: WILLOW!

Willow: I don’t hope so! I’m sorry, I don’t know what to say!

Olive went to a corner, and wept openly.

Olive Specter (Muenda) left at altar by Earl E DeMise

Olive: (thinking) Accident, huh? I’ll make him have one if he doesn’t show up here now!

A few minutes later, the guests began leaving.

Olive changed back to her Everyday wear, and crept over to Earl’s house to check if he was at home.

Olive Specter spies on Earl E & Tim Lee DeMise in the hot tub

True enough, from her hiding place in the bushes, she spotted Earl E and his brother, Tim Lee DeMise, talking in the hot tub.

Olive: (thinking) What is that oil-dealing snake doing there? He was supposed to be giving me the “yes-word” today, but now he’s pretending it’s just a regular day. I’m going to give you and your brother the “shock” of your life…

Earl E: Yeah bro, I never want to see her ever again. She was so pushy, and expected me to live in her fantasy bubble. But I could never settle down with such a crazy chick anyway. I was just having her for fun, but she was always so serious.

I’d rather marry a Crafthole (^) girl. They might be unclean, but at least they have a sense of humor, and they can brew the best Bloody Moss Ale (^).

Earl E DeMise & Tim Lee DeMise talking in the hot tub

Tim Lee: I feel you. She wasn’t worth your time, you almost… Wait, look over there! That bush is on fire! Help me extinguish it!

The DeMise brothers exited the hot tub, and ran to extinguish the fire.

Earl E & Tim Lee DeMise run from the hot tub

Olive quickly tampered with the hot tub, then rushed back into hiding.

Young Olive Specter tampers with the hot tub

Earl E: Why would a bush burst into flames like that?

Tim Lee: Maybe that crazy witch cast a spell on us.

Earl E: Haha, maybe we’re Cursed for life (^) now! Pathetic. I expect a bag of flaming poo on our doorstep next.

Olive: (thinking) “For life”? Oh, yours won’t last much longer…

The DeMise brothers went back into the hot tub. Moments later, they both died by electrocution.

Earl E DeMise & Tim Lee DeMise die by electrocution

Olive stood staring at a familiar dark-hooded figure, who lingered longer to collect two sims’ souls at once.

She was so awestruck that she could barely speak. It had been a decade since she last saw the Grim Reaper, and she wondered when she could see him again.

Second meeting of young Olive Specter and Grim Reaper Thanatos Grimm

Olive wanted to cash in on Earl E’s money for herself. Sadly, he was a Compulsive Gambler (^), so all his money went into paying his debts. Olive could not take residence in his manor either, as Earl had already given it up as a collateral, since his money alone was not enough to pay the full debt.

(^) References to the game Sims Medieval.

(#) Jenny Smith was the only Curious sibling who was old enough to have any memory of the Danielle Greaves incident, as seen in STSYC #2.

How would Olive’s experience with Earl E. shape her future romantic choices?
How deep was her obsession with the Grim Reaper?
Find out in the [next chapter]

Olive Specter’s Timeline (STSYC Prequel)

1. Early Years: Danielle Greaves, Earl E. DeMise

2. DJ Spectra: Rigger Mortis, Hugh Thanasia

3. Midnight Hollow: Thanatos Grimm, Nervous Subject, Doe Family, Ichabod Specter

4. Elder Guardian: Ophelia Nigmos, Lyla Grunt, Strangetown Bella Goth / Jane Doe

STSYC Chapters:

1. The Pleas
2. Pizza and Family Gatherings
3. One In, One Out?
4. The First Battle
5. Two More Teams Join the Fray
6. The Second Battle
7. Liaisons
8. The Third Battle
9. Ultimatums
10A. New Challenges
10B. New Beginnings

STSYC Bloopers
StrangeTown Families Timelines / Lola & Chloe’s Age Discrepancy

2 Replies to “Olive Specter’s Timeline #1: Early Years – Danielle Greaves, Earl E. DeMise”

  1. Wow, Olive didn’t hang around when it came to the killing – I guess whatever you want to be it pays to start young 😮 😛

    1. Olive is intelligent, decisive and careful. We wonder what brilliant career she may have had, if she didn’t turn to the dark side… unless serial killing counts as her unofficial profession? 😮

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: