Olive Specter’s Timeline #3: Midnight Hollow: Thanatos Grimm, Nervous Subject, Doe Family, Ichabod Specter

(23 years before STSYC)

Midnight Hollow was known for its eccentricity. For years, it proved to be a safe and comfortable city of refuge for Olive Specter.

After placing her three favorite “trophies” in her new yard, the place felt just like home.

By this time, the Grim Reaper, Thanatos Grimm, finally decided to reciprocate Olive’s special feelings towards him.

Thanatos Grimm (Grim Reaper) acts on his feelings for Olive Specter

Olive knew that this romance was different, for two reasons.

Firstly, despite being married more than once, her only significant woohoo memory was with Thanatos, whom she was not married to. Olive was bemused at how messed up her love life was.

Secondly, if Thanatos Grimm annoyed her, she definitely could NOT kill him.

So Olive had finally found a formidable lover whom she had a genuine deep connection with, and considered to be an equal.

Olive Specter & Thanatos Grimm (Grim Reaper) on the bed

That moment was beautiful while it lasted. When it was over, Olive
was sad, because she knew she could not possibly become Mrs Grimm, since Thanatos was not mortal.

Thanatos suggested that they could “have another round”. This time, he would “give her something to remember him by”.

Olive Specter & Thanatos Grimm (Grim Reaper) spend more time together

Olive was not sure whether to believe him or not, but she enjoyed the moment with every fiber of her being. Decades later, she would still be replaying this encounter over and over in her head, as one of her favorite memories.

Olive Specter pregnant with Grim Reaper spawn

So when Olive’s belly became enlarged, she was surprised, as she didn’t expect that a supernatural being could give her a child.

When her baby boy was born with skintone 1, she was even more bewildered, since this was too far apart from her family’s usual skintone 4. But this child was of supernatural origin, so Olive concluded that typical DNA mixing rules may not apply in this case.

Olive Specter's new baby, Nervous Subject

She looked into the face of her newborn son, who was a twitchy infant. Only one word came to her head…

“NERVOUS”… and the nickname stuck, regardless of the filler “proper name” she had to declare on his birth certificate.

Olive loved her son. She thought her life was finally complete, with the son from the love of her life.

Olive Specter & toddler Nervous Subject

Alas, life was not perfect, because Olive had an ongoing grudge against the “perfect mother” Jane Doe, a resident of Midnight Hollow. From the outset, Mrs Doe had taken an instant dislike to Olive and Nervous, and had the habit of making fun of them, ruining many nice outings at the playground.

Midnight Hollow's Jane Doe insults Olive Specter & toddler Nervous Subject at the playground, where the young Racing Men are playing

“He’s so skinny. You should feed him more often. Oh, and may I suggest less frogs for dinner!”

“Are you sure he’s even yours? Your skintones are so far apart!”

“He’s always twitching, Olive. He lacks any charm… unlike my charming kids: Joseph, Jennifer and James!”

Jane Doe thinks Nervous Subject lacks charm. Olive Specter tries hard to control herself, while Lucien Hyde tries not to get involved.

Olive bit her lip throughout all these insults. She dared not risk reacting, or it may trigger her old murderous tendencies. She had to think about Nervous.

Olive Specter & Nervous Subject can't seem to escape from Jane Doe's trolling presence at the playground, while the young Racing Men concentrate on their sports drills

When that was not enough, Jane Doe decided to call Social Services, greatly exaggerating the matter of Olive’s alleged “abuse” of her child. The Social Workers took this “worried” call for granted.

Olive Specter tries in vain to stop the Social Worker from taking Nervous Subject away

“You evil witch! Don’t you dare take Nervous away!”

Nervous? What kind of name is that? If that’s the name you gave him, you’re certainly not fit to be a parent!”

“Mommy!! Mommy… help….ahhhhh!!! Mommy….” (#)

That was the last line Olive heard from her toddler son, while sobbing as if her world had collapsed.

Toddler Nervous Subject & Olive Specter cry at their separation

This was the last straw that broke the camel’s back. Olive decided to take revenge on Jane Doe. After all, “charm” was worthless when Mrs Doe was dead.

Olive Specter kills Jane Doe

Olive had originally intended to kill only Jane. But Jane’s husband, John Doe, and all their kids came home at the wrong time.

Doe family - John, Joseph, Jennifer, James are shocked

So Olive decided to do away with all the witnesses too…

Olive Specter kills the rest of the Doe family

Or so she thought.

Olive Specter walks away from the crime scene, seen only by Lucien Hyde

The only witness, Lucien Hyde, a Midnight Hollow resident, only saw Olive coming out of the Doe house. At that time, he had no idea why Olive was there.

Even when the police appealed for witnesses to come forward, Lucien Hyde decided to stay silent, because he did not think this matter was worth his time.

Midnight Hollow's Lucien Hyde decides to hold his peace, while young Prometheus Hyde and his Racing Men peers bond at the playground

There was no time to collect trophies from the Doe house this time. Olive had to pack up and leave again, in case the cops decided to pay her another visit.

Olive decided to return to StrangeTown. After extracting all her other hidden “trophies” from the creepy underground vault, she arranged them all nicely outside her new home in 13 Dead End Lane – the estate which would be later known to the other StrangeTown residents as “Specter Yard”.

Olive & Ichabod Specter at Chef Gino pizzeria

ICHABOD SPECTER (10 years before STSYC)

Olive took a short holiday in the island of Gastrobury (^). While feasting at the “Chef Gino” pizzeria, she met Ichabod Specter.

Olive immediately felt a genuine connection towards Ichabod, something she never felt with any of her former husbands and ex-fiancé… but this was similar to what she felt towards Thanatos Grimm.

Perhaps Ichabod’s surname, “Specter”, played a part in this impression that she was meant to be with him, since she had an affinity for the names “Spectra” and “Specter” long before she even met Ichabod.

When Olive told Ichabod she was going back to Strangetown, he immediately told Olive he was coming with her, leaving the beautiful medievalesque island behind with all its great recipes and the legendary “Gastro-Fest” (^), to live with her in a desert town with a graveyard.

Wedding of Ichabod & Olive Specter, attended by Willow, Creon and Ophelia Nigmos

But that did not bother Ichabod. As Olive was already an elder, Ichabod was clearly not looking for an heir. All he wanted was to be with her, and to set up a restaurant one mile outside Strangetown.

Olive & Ichabod Specter enjoy a meal together

However, the latter never came to pass. The Specters spent one happy year together, before Ichabod died peacefully of Old Age.

Olive Specter mourns at Ichabod's grave

Olive was devastated. She had never felt such grief before, because she never before felt such a deep connection with a mortal man.

Of course, this was the time for her immortal lover to appear.

Thanatos Grimm (Grim Reaper) visits Olive Specter

“Olive, you loved him, didn’t you?”

“Yes. Ichabod was the only husband I truly loved. You can’t blame me, Thanatos, because you are immortal and out of reach to me.”

“I understand, Olive. Take your time to grieve. But there’s another thing… our boy is still lost, isn’t he?

“Do you know where he is?”

Olive Specter wonders if Thanatos Grimm (Grim Reaper) can help

“Alas, my immortal power has its limits. I only know he’s not with you, but I can’t sense where he is.”

“Can you find him?”

“No, I can’t, because I can’t overstay too long in the mortal realm. But I have another gift for you. It may help you get our boy back.”

With a whiff of his scythe, Thanatos Grimm produced a skull phone, and presented it to Olive Specter.

Thanatos Grimm (Grim Reaper) presents a skull phone (Resurrect-O-Nomitron) to Olive Specter

Olive stared in amazement. “How do I use this to get Nervous back?”

“Nervous?” Thanatos looked askance, but decided against questioning Olive’s taste in nicknames. “You will know how to use this when it’s time, Olive dear.”

Olive Specter asks Thanatos Grimm (Grim Reaper) about the skull phone

With that, the Grim Reaper disappeared again, leaving Olive to inspect his latest gift. She was still grieving too deeply to make much sense of the supernatural contraption before her.

The loss of Ichabod, the only husband Olive ever loved, felt like retribution for all her past bloody deeds.

She decided to honor her short marriage by using Ichabod’s surname, Specter, sometimes in place of her own first name. That is why the Strangetown residents sometimes refer to her only as “Specter”, instead of just “Olive”.

(^) References to the game Sims Medieval.

(#) Nervous’ last cry for help as a toddler is almost identical to the first plea that Olive heard from him as an adult in [STSYC #1].

Notes from the Authors: Retconning and Names in Midnight Hollow (Nervous Subject)

Prior to Midnight Hollow’s release, fans have suggested different birth names for Nervous Subject, ranging from Osiris to Neville, since “Nervous Subject” was logically interpreted as a cruel nickname from the Beakers, instead of a proper name given by his mother.

Likewise, it is probably a marketing reason behind the choice to retain the name “Nervous Subject” for this character at this early life stage in Midnight Hollow, so he is recognizable alongside his mother.

Fixing a canonical “proper birth name” for Nervous also risks invalidating the many fan fiction tales written before Midnight Hollow’s release.

So in STSYC, the authors chose a middle-ground approach, so that “Nervous Subject” is a nickname that Olive had already used on her toddler son, used so often that his “proper birth name”, if any, is forgotten and irrelevant in this tale.

How much does Olive miss having a child in her life?
Will old age mellow her murderous instincts?
Find out in the [next chapter]

Olive Specter’s Timeline (STSYC Prequel)

1. Early Years: Danielle Greaves, Earl E. DeMise

2. DJ Spectra: Rigger Mortis, Hugh Thanasia

3. Midnight Hollow: Thanatos Grimm, Nervous Subject, Doe Family, Ichabod Specter

4. Elder Guardian: Ophelia Nigmos, Lyla Grunt, Strangetown Bella Goth / Jane Doe

STSYC Chapters:

1. The Pleas
2. Pizza and Family Gatherings
3. One In, One Out?
4. The First Battle
5. Two More Teams Join the Fray
6. The Second Battle
7. Liaisons
8. The Third Battle
9. Ultimatums
10A. New Challenges
10B. New Beginnings

STSYC Bloopers
StrangeTown Families Timelines / Lola & Chloe’s Age Discrepancy

4 Replies to “Olive Specter’s Timeline #3: Midnight Hollow: Thanatos Grimm, Nervous Subject, Doe Family, Ichabod Specter”

  1. Funny, I never actually knew Olive and Ichabod got married as elders – shame the best marriage came so late 😦

    1. It’s sad that Olive’s happiness was rarely prolonged. Sometimes I wonder if she would have even gone down this dark path if she had been a happy person in the first place.

      In sims 2, there’s a canon family album pic of olive and ichabod getting married as elders, albeit without the nigmos family clearly in attendance. The sims 3 midnight hollow retconned timing of ichabod’s death to be before or around the time of nervous’ toddlerhood may have contributed to that impression.

  2. Strangely Jennifer Doe (I think that’s the child’s name) is smiling and crying at the same time. Perhaps their perfect life already had holes in it. Having Racing men and Hyde in the background is both interesting and mildly amusing.
    I wonder how Willow and Creon will die in this story.

    1. This version of the Doe family (recreated in sims 2 by sims2player) has their “neutral” expression tilted upwards in perpetual smiles (see their newly added family shot in STSYC 3). Interesting interpretation that their so-called perfect lives aren’t actually perfect, which is usually true anyway.

      Midnight Hollow is the earliest time period in OST that the RM could possibly crash, if we wish to avoid a time anomaly like in GODP 2 (I disguised the teen cameos more heavily because the RM are not supposed to be in Daniel Pleasant’s age group). But the RM are indeed slightly older than Nervous, so the playground was the right place.

      We’ll find out how the nigmos tragedy unfurls… after the WC 2018 finals 😉

Comments are closed.